Is ReplyGuy worth it?
Finds mentions on Reddit and X, then writes the reply for you.
What is ReplyGuy?
ReplyGuy scans Reddit and X for your keywords, scores each match for relevance and sentiment, then drafts the reply. Every plan buys a fixed number of replies a month, from 100 to 5,000, so the cost tracks how much you actually engage.
Best for: Volume reply generation across Reddit and X
ReplyGuy pricing
Starts at $39/mo
$199 a year. Entry tier.
100 replies a month. $349 a year.
300 replies a month. $699 a year.
1,000 replies a month. $1,399 a year.
5,000 replies a month. $3,499 a year.
* Read from replyguy.com/#pricing on 2026-08-20. Tiers move often, so confirm before you pay.
Strengths & Limitations
What ReplyGuy does well, and where it falls short
An honest breakdown based on published features, third-party reviews, and their own disclosures.
What's good
- Relevance scoring and sentiment on every tier, not just the expensive ones
- Covers X alongside Reddit, which most Reddit-only tools do not
- Yearly billing takes five months off the price
Where it falls short
- Every tier meters replies, so the cost tracks your volume
- Entry is $39 a month, no longer the cheap way in it used to be
- No Slack, webhook or API on the public tiers
Feature checklist
What ReplyGuy does
The same checklist we apply to every tool. An amber badge means the feature exists, but only on a higher tier.
* Checked against ReplyGuy's own pages on 2026-08-20.
ReplyGuy FAQ
Common questions about ReplyGuy's features, pricing, and fit
Still have a question? Email us.
Your next customers are on Reddit right now
Stop scrolling Reddit by hand. We find the conversations that matter and you turn them into customers.
What are you all using for a 40 person team?
Anyone happy with their listening stack?
Need something that does not cost a fortune
Best uptime monitoring for a small team?